[MPWG] Jatropha Fever in India

[pankaj oudhia]

Greetings to the Group,
          I am forwarding recent article published on Jatropha promotion and its impact on Indian states for your reference.The article has appeared in Down to Earth Vol 13 ,No 13 November  30, 2004
 

Why is the Chhattisgarh government promoting a poisonous and invasive plant, asks Pankaj Oudhia 
The government of Chhattisgarh is on a mission to promote jatro- pha. It has planted 6 lakh saplings in the last six months and has requested additional funds from the Union government to plant more jatrophas. On face of it, promoting the plant makes good sense: jatropha has medicinal uses and bio diesel can be extract- ed from its seeds. 
But the Chhattisgarh government has forgotten that jatropha is also a very poisonous weed: many developed countries today spend huge sums of money to eliminate it. The plant is actually native to tropical America and today occurs in most parts of India. In Chhattisgarh, people use its wild varieties for making fences to keep out animals. Traditional healers in the state also use parts of jatropha for making medicines, but they concede that this is a very recent usage. 
More importantly, these healers also admit that jatropha outcom- petes other plants in its vicinity. One shudders to think what ecological mayhem might ensue once the government's large jatro- pha plantations come into their own. Introducing this plant without conducting proper feasibility studies has put Chhattisgarh's rich biodiversity in serious jeopardy. 
Moreover, where is the potential market for jatropha-diesel? The government claims that its low cost will draw enough buyers. But is such bio diesel really cheap? No. 
In fact, at Rs 150 (or even more) per litre, it is nearly five times the cost of conventional diesel. The Chhattisgarh govern- ment is perhaps oblivious of the experiments of some African countries with jatropha. A few decades back, governments of these countries had promoted jatropha as a biofuel yielding plant. 
Did these projects have any success? No. These countries continue to rely on conventional diesel. 
But the Chhattisgarh government has little time for such argu- ments. Every department is under the jatropha fever. Panchayat members have been roped in to plant saplings around village ponds and even the railways have taken to cultivating the plant in its wasteland. This is not all: schools have also been targeted for plantation - this, when local people live in perpetual scare of their children falling sick (even dying) after consuming the sweet but poisonous jatropha seeds. 
And who exactly has prospered from the government's frenetic zeal to promote Jatropha? The biggest beneficiaries have been the few suppliers who deal in the plant. These suppliers sell a jatropha sapling for Rs 6, sometimes, even Rs 10 although ideally one sapling should cost only Rs 0.50-Rs 0.90. 
This is not to say that Chhattisgarh's farmers have shown no enthusiasm for the 'wonder plant'. In fact in Tilda district, there are jatropha plantations over 40 hectares of land. Many in the state have prospered and are now supplying the herb to dif- ferent parts of India. But the question remains: is the venture sustainable? 
If the Chhattisgarh government is really serious in promoting jatropha over the long term, it should conduct feasibility stud- ies. A pilot project should be undertaken in areas that have natural jatropha population; at the same time, the exotic varie- ties should be weeded out. The use of endemic plants will provide employment opportunities to local people; rooting out the exotic species would give much needed relief to the native flora. 
Moreover, if the Chhattisgarh government is so confident about using jatropha as a bio diesel, it should start a scheme to buy back the plants from the farmers. Only unscrupulous suppliers stand to lose from these moves. Already, many exotic plants such as eupatorium, eucalyptus, lantana and water hyacinths have caused enough damage to Chhattisgarh's biodiversity. The govern- ment should not compound matters any further. If the government is really keen on promoting bio diesel it should consider locally available plants such as the karanj (Pongamia). 
The writer is convenor, International Parthenium Research News Group and a member of Global Invasive Species Information Net- work)
 ==================
regards
Pankaj Oudhia
http://www.pankajoudhia.com

Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your life partneronline.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.plantconservation.org/pipermail/mpwg_lists.plantconservation.org/attachments/20041128/b7b7b2d2/attachment.html>